History 1010-100:
Western Civilization from Antiquity to the Seventeenth
Century
FALL 2010
Humanities Building (DUAN)
G1B30
Lectures MW: 8:00-8:50pm
Recitation TBA
Professor Lester
Office Hours: M: 9:30-10:30 & W: 11:30-1:00pm
Office: Hellems 348
and by appointment
E-mail: alester@colorado.edu
Course Description
This
course explores the origins and development of western societies from the
ancient period through the seventeenth century. We will focus on the changes and continuities that
characterize the civilizations of the west with a particular eye to the
European and Mediterranean world.
We will also analyze when societies collapse and how they are reformed
and question the ways that historians characterize ruptures and breaks in the
past as well as renaissances and renewals. The lectures proceed chronologically and fall (roughly) into three
thematic sections (a) Ancient Worlds (b) Medieval Civilizations (c) Early
Modern Societies. The course emphasizes several themes
including: the generation of large political entities such as empires and
states; the process of urbanization; the role of law; the significance of
economic systems and long distance trade networks; as well as changes in
religion and the rise of monotheism; the meaning of gender; and the power of
ideologies in the cultural formation of societies.
Course Objectives and Goals
The
course is intended to provide students with a broad overview of western
civilization and specifically European society from the first evidence of
written culture to ca. 1600, when the more familiar lines of modern nation
states begin to be drawn. It is
also intended to provide students with an introduction to the discipline of
history and historical analysis. By looking closely, in lectures and
discussions at the written and cultural products of these societies students
will develop an understanding of how individuals lived in, thought about, and
shaped their worlds in the past. The lectures are intended to provide an
historical framework that will help you to contextualize and better understand
the reading assignments. Lectures are designed to complement the reading in the
textbook and the primary sources. At times the lectures will focus on specific
themes and examples, offering an in-depth portrait of a particular historical
development intended to flesh out ideas in the texts from a different
perspective.
The reading assignments are English
translations of works by ancient, medieval and early modern philosophers,
poets, monks, nuns, clerics, and playwrights. In their words, we can hear the
voices of the long distant past expressing the ideals and concerns of their
societies. To this end, students will
learn to read and analyze primary sources in translations as well as engage the
arguments of current historians by reading and discussing several focused
articles throughout the semester. The goal of discussions is to consider these texts in the
spirit of free and generous exchange of ideas, which is an integral component of
the western intellectual tradition. Moreover, many of the texts that we will
analyze in these meetings will be relevant to the essay questions that comprise
exams.
In
addition to providing a basic overview of western history in these centuries,
the course also seeks to teach students the basic components of historical
thinking and writing. We will
discuss what sorts of questions can fruitfully be asked of particular types of
sources and consider seemingly contradictory points of view set forth by the
evidence as well as by historians who have interpreted past events in light of
these sources. Finally, students
will learn to present their own conclusions, ideas, and theses clearly and
persuasively in both discussions and in written form on exams and in papers.
Requirements
and Evaluation
Attendance
and Participation in Recitations (20%):
Attendance
at lectures and recitation sections is required. Grades for participation are assessed on just that: participation in recitation discussion. This course privileges an active
engagement with the primary source texts and a willingness to take risks by offering
ones opinions, raising important issues of interpretation, and asking
questions of our sources. Please come prepared to raise questions (indeed, it
is a good idea to generate questions and write them down beforehand) and
participate. Always bring
the weekly reading assignment with you to the recitation meetings.
**
Course policy on recitations: If you
miss more than one unexcused recitation you will receive a failing grade
for this portion of the course. If you miss more than three unexcused
recitations you will NOT receive a passing grade in the course overall.
Written
Assignments (20%):
History
entails the study of written culture.
Historians depend on written documents and sources from the past, just
as they produce written syntheses of such material to form an argumentative
picture of past societies.
Writing, therefore, is fundamental to the discipline of history. In light of this you will be asked to
write two papers. The first will analyze the epic poem the Iliad, by Homer (10%) and the second paper will focus on our final
primary source, Shakespeares play Hamlet
(10%). Guidelines and questions
relating to each assignment will be handed out beforehand. All late assignments
will be graded down one whole letter grade for each day they are late. There
may also be shorter written assignments relating to each recitation meeting to
be determined by your TA.
Exams
(60%):
There
will be three exams that will punctuate the course (worth 20% each). Exams will focus on material discussed
in depth in lecture and during the discussions and will draw upon terms and
ideas presented in lecture rather than in the textbook. Indeed the textbook is considered a
supplement to the lecture material rather than the other way around. Should you miss a significant number of
lectures for any reason is it extremely unlikely that you will pass the exam.
**To receive a
passing grade in this course your must complete ALL of the assigned work **
Texts
All
texts listed below are available for purchase at the CU bookstore and are also
on reserve in Norlin Library.
The Making of the West: Peoples and Cultures Volume I: To 1740 –
A Concise History, ed. Lynn Hunt, et al. (NY: Bedford/St. Martins, 2010).
Homer, The Iliad. trans. Robert Flagels (Penguin Classics, 1998).
Augustus and the Creation of the Roman Empire: A Brief History with
Documents,
ed. Ronald Mellor (NY: Bedford/St. Martins, 2006).
Power and the Holy in the Age of the Investiture Conflict: A Brief
History with Documents, ed. Maureen C. Miller (NY: Bedford/St. Martins, 2005).
Letters of Abelard and Heloise, ed. Betty Radice and Michael Clanchy (NY: Penguin
Classics, 2004) (Revised edition).
The Black Death: The Great Mortality of 1348-1350: A Brief History with
Documents,
ed. John Aberth (NY: Bedford/St. Martins 2005).
William Shakespeare, Hamlet, ed. Sylvan Barnet (Signet
Classics, 1998).
In
addition to the books available for purchase we will also read several excerpts
of shorter primary sources as well as three scholarly articles. This material, listed below, is
available on e-reserve. E-reserves
must be accessed through the Norlin Library catalog at: http://libraries.colorado.edu/screens/coursereserves.html,
once there, follow the prompts for the professors name [LESTER] or course
title [HIST 1010-001] and print out the specific texts.
Articles/Readings:
Brent D. Shaw, On the
Passion of Perpetua, Past and Present 139 (1993): 3-45.
Michael McCormick, New
Light on the Dark Ages: How the Slave Trade Fuelled the Carolingian Economy,
Past & Present 177 (2002): 17-54.
Selections from Bede, Ecclesiastical History of
the English People (New York, revised ed. 1990).
Selection from Fred Donner, Muhammad and the
Believers: At the Origins of Islam (Cambridge, MA, 2010) – Chapter 2.
The
course syllabus and lecture outlines will be available on the course WEBSITE:
http://spot.colorado.edu/~alester/Courses/History_1010/syllabus.html
You
may follow the links on the syllabus under each lecture date to the
corresponding lecture outline. These outlines will be posted during the week of
the lecture.
Other Important Matters
Academic Integrity and the Course Environment
Academic integrity means
upholding the highest standards in the performance of your course work. Taking pride in the formation,
acknowledgement, and execution of your own ideas, from conception through to
the final written product, is part of the academic and intellectual process. To
violate or alter this by taking ideas or written material from another source
(be it a fellow student, a published book, article or website) is both morally
dishonest as well as breach of the Universitys Honor Code. Moreover, it
compromises the goals and purposes of academic study under any circumstances. Academic integrity is as much about your
own personal moral responsibilities as it is about your grade in this course.
Plagiarism
and the Honor Code
All
students of the University of Colorado at Boulder are responsible for knowing
and adhering to the academic integrity policy of this institution. Violations
of this policy may include: cheating, plagiarism, aid of academic dishonesty,
fabrication, lying, bribery, and threatening behavior. All incidents of
academic misconduct shall be reported to the Honor Code Council (honor@colorado.edu; 303-725-2273).
Students who are found to be in violation of the academic integrity
policy will be subject to both academic sanctions from the faculty member and
non-academic sanctions (including by not limited to university probation,
suspension or expulsion). Additional information on the Honor Code can be found
at
http://www.colorado.edu/policies/honor.html
http://www.colorado.edu/academics/honorcode/
If you are found to be in violation of the Honor Code
in this course, specifically if you plagiarize any material whatsoever, you
will receive a Grade of F for the course.
Personal
Conduct and Behavior
Students and faculty each have responsibility for maintaining an
appropriate learning environment. Students who fail to adhere to such
behavioral standards may be subject to discipline. Faculty have the professional responsibility to treat all
students with understanding, dignity and respect, to guide classroom discussion
and to set reasonable limits on the manner in which they and their students
express opinions. Professional
courtesy and sensitivity are especially important with respect to individuals
and topics dealing with differences of race, culture, religion, politics,
sexual orientation, gender, gender variance, and nationalities. Class rosters are provided to the
instructor with the student's legal name. I will gladly honor your request to
address you by an alternate name or gender pronoun. Please advise me of this preference early in the semester so
that I may make appropriate changes to my records. See polices at:
http://www.colorado.edu/policies/classbehavior.htmland
at http://www.colorado.edu/studentaffairs/judicialaffairs/code.html#student_code
The University of Colorado at Boulder policy on Discrimination and
Harassment, the University of Colorado policy on Sexual Harassment and the
University of Colorado policy on Amorous Relationships apply to all students,
staff and faculty. Any student,
staff or faculty member who believes s/he has been the subject of discrimination
or harassment based upon race, color, national origin, sex, age, disability,
religion, sexual orientation, or veteran status should contact the Office of
Discrimination and Harassment (ODH) at 303-492-2127 or the Office of Judicial
Affairs at 303-492-5550.
Information about the ODH, the above referenced policies and the campus
resources available to assist individuals regarding discrimination or
harassment can be obtained at http://www.colorado.edu/odh
Students
with Disabilities
If
you qualify for accommodations because of a disability, please submit a letter
to me from Disability Services in a timely manner so that your needs may be
addressed. Disability Services determines accommodations based on documented
disabilities. Please contact: 303/492-8671, Willard 322 or http://www.colorado.edu/disabilityservices
Religious
Observances/Class Absences
Attendance
in this course is required for both lectures and discussion. Please notify me
early in the semester if you anticipate that you may miss a class meeting so
that there is adequate time to make necessary arrangements. If you are absent
for more than three unexcused class meetings your participation grade will be
an automatic F.
Campus
policy regarding religious observances requires that faculty make every effort
to reasonably and fairly deal with all students who, because of religious
obligations, have conflicts with scheduled exams, assignments or required
attendance. See policy details at:
http:/www.colorado.edu/policies/fac
relig.html and http://www.interfaithcalendar.org/
Schedule of Lectures, Readings, and Discussion
[L] = Lecture
[T] = Textbook: The Making of the West, Hunt, Rosenwein, et al.
Week 1 – Foundations
and Texts: Locating the West and its Civilizations
[M: Aug. 23] – L1: Introductions – The Syllabus and the Study of the History of the West. Listen to First Lecture Podcast (download | slides)
[W: Aug. 25] – L2: The Earliest Civilizations Listen to Second Lecture Podcast (download | slides)
No recitation meetings this week. Listen to Podcast Lectures 1 & 2. Send a letter to Prof. Lester.
Week 2 – The
Ancient World
[M: Aug. 30] – L3: The Ancient Near East (slides)
[W: Sep. 1] – L4: Politics and Reason in Classical Greece (slides)
Read: [T]: Chapter 1, pp. 1-49; Begin Homer, The Iliad.
Recitation Topic: Ancient Society and Written Culture—Comments on Reading Primary Documents
Week 3 – Hellenism
and the Mediterranean
[M: Sep. 6] – NO CLASS – Labor Day Holiday
[W: Sep. 8] – L5: The Hellenistic Kingdoms (slides)
Read: [T]: Chapter 2, pp. 51-89; Continue The Iliad – through Book 12.
Recitation Topic: Kingship, Consensus and Reason among the Greeks
Week 4 – Rome:
From Kingdom to Republic
[M: Sep. 13] – L6: The Rise of Rome (slides)
[W: Sep 15] – L7: From
Republic to the First Among Equals
Read: [T]: Chapter 3, pp. 91-127; Finish The Iliad.
Recitation Topic: Revenge, Anger, and the Wrath of Men in the Greek World
Week 5 – Rome:
Empire and Expansion
[M: Sep. 20] – L8: The Roman Empire and its Frontiers
(slides)A **5-page
paper on The Iliad due at the
beginning of class on MONDAY
[W: Sep 22] – L9: Emergence of Christianity
(slides)Read: [T]: Chapter 4, pp. 129-169; Ronald Mellor, Augustus and the Creation of the Roman Empire. Selections: Introduction, pp. 59-68, 74-76, 82-95, 102-105, 108-122, 133-136, 139-141, 152-154, 156-157, 160-166.
Recitation Topic: Augustus and the Imperial Image
Week 6 –Late
Antiquity and the Christianization of Empire
[M: Sep. 27] – L10: The Third Century Crisis and the Making of Martyrdom
(slides)[W: Sep. 29] – L11: Spread of Christianity: Constantine and the Bishops
(slides) Read: [T]: Chapter 5, pp. 171-211. The Passion of Saints Perpetua and Felicity
(on e-reserve); and Brent D. Shaw, On
the Passion of Perpetua, Past and Present 139 (1993): 3-45 (on e-reserve).
Recitation Topic: Gender, Christianity and the Roman State – Review for Exam
Week 7 – The
Fall and Its Aftermath
[M: Oct. 4] – L12: The Fall of Rome, the Coming of the Huns, and the German Tribes
(slides)[W: Oct. 6] – L13: First Exam : The End of the Ancient World ,
Read: [T]: Chapter 6, p. 213-235.
Recitation Topic: No recitation meeting this week.
Week 8 – Emergence of the European West
[M: Oct. 11] – L14: The Rise of Islam
(slides)[W: Oct. 13] – L15: The Western Church and Its Kingdoms
(slides)Read: [T]: Chapter 6, pp. 235-257, and Chapter 7, pp. 259-293. Selections from Fred Donner, Muhammad and the Believers; and Bede, The Ecclesiastical History of the English People (on e-reserve)
Recitation Topic: Islam and the West: Making Muslims and Christians
Week 9 – Reform and Renewal
[M: Oct. 18] – L16: Carolingian Kingship and Culture
(slides)[W: Oct. 20] – L17: The Gregorian Reform
(slides)Read: [T]: Chapter 8, pp. 271-309; and Michael McCormick, New Light on the Dark Ages: How the Slave Trade Fuelled the Carolingian Economy, Past & Present 177 (2002): 17-54 (on e-reserve).
Recitation Topic: Points of Contact: Controlling and Constructing a Contested Sea
Week 10 – Reformation of the Twelfth Century
[M: Oct. 25] – L18: The First Crusade and the Expansion of Europe
(slides)[W: Oct. 27] – L19: Monasticism and the Twelfth-Century Renaissance
(slides)Read: [T]: Chapter 9, pp. 311-351; Maureen C. Miller, Power and the Holy in the Age of the Investiture Conflict: A Brief History with Documents – Selections: Introduction, pp. 45- 121, 132-138.
Recitation Topic: The Meaning of Reform and the Rise of the
Medieval Papacy
Week 11 – Intellectual
Culture in Medieval Europe
[M: Nov. 1] – L20: The Rise of the Universities
(slides)[W: Nov. 3] -- L21: Urban Culture
and the Fourth Lateran Council
Read: [T]: Chapter 10, pp. 353-391; The Letters of Abelard and Heloise – Read the Introduction and Letters 1-6, pp. 1-111.
Recitation Topic: Desire and Asceticism: Finding a Female Voice? – Review for Exam
Week 12 – Europe
in the High Middle Ages
[M: Nov. 8] – L22: France and the Medieval State
(slides)[W: Nov. 10] – L23: Second Exam: Transformations of Medieval Society
Read: [T]: Review Chapters 6-10 for exam;
Recitation Topic: No recitation meeting this week.
Week 13 – The
Transition to Early Modern Europe
[M: Nov. 15] – L24: The
Calamities of the Fourteenth Century – The Black Death
[W: Nov. 17] – L25: Humanism and an Italian Renaissance
(slides)Read: [T]: Chapter 11, pp. 425-471; John Aberth, The Black Death: The Great Mortality of 1348-1350: A Brief History with Documents – Selections: Introduction, pp. 9-66, 75-82, 87-91, 106-110, 117-137, 160-178
Recitation Topic: The Other Side of the Divide: Early Modern Europe and a New Perspective?
NO CLASS -- THANKSGIVING
BREAK -- (enjoy!)
November 22-26
Week 15 – Reformation
and Response
[M: Nov. 29] – L26: Print Culture and the Protestant Movement
(slides)[W: Dec. 1] – L27: The Case of England – The Stripping of the Altars
(slides)Read: [T]: Chapter 12, pp. 473-521; Shakespeare, Hamlet
Recitation Topic: Hamlet – One mans struggle with religion and politics
Week 16 – Three
New Worlds
[M: Dec. 6] – L28: The Catholic Response and the Export of Catholic Culture
(slides)A **Final
Paper (5-pages) on Hamlet due at the
beginning of class Wednesday Dec. 8th **
[W: Dec. 8] – L29: Science and the Self: Macrocosms and Microcosms – Some Brief Concluding Remarks
(slides)Read: [T]: Chapter 13, pp. 523-565.
Recitation Topic: Review for Exam
Third Exam: The Early Modern World –Wednesday 15 December 2010, 7:30-10:00pm
Please remember to bring your Bluebooks!!
Guidelines Related to Grading and Written Assignments in the Course:
An A or A- paper, written assignment or exam
demonstrates an exemplary command of the course material. Such assignments
offer a close and critical reading of the texts and a consideration of issues
raised in the course as a whole, offer a synthesis of the readings,
discussions, and lectures and present a perceptive, compelling, independent
argument. They are clearly written and well-organized. The argument or thesis
shows intellectual originality and creativity (a willingness to take risks with
ideas and interpretations), are attuned to historical context, supported by a
well-chosen variety of specific examples from the texts, and (in the case of
papers) rely upon a critical reading of primary material.
A B+ or B paper, written assignment, or exam
shares many aspects in common with A-level work, but falls short in either the
organization and clarity of its writing (stylistically), the formation and
presentation of its argument (organizationally), or in the quality and level of
critical engagement (substantively).
A B-
paper, written assignment or exam demonstrates a command of the course material
and a general understanding of the historical context but offers a less than
thorough presentation of the writers independent thesis due to weakness in
writing, argument, organization or presentation of evidence.
A C+, C, or C- paper, written assignment, or exam offers little more than a
summary of ideas and information covered in the course or presented in the
specific question. They are insensitive to the historical context, do not
respond to the assignment adequately, suffer from factual errors, unclear
writing, lack of organization, or inadequate use of evidence, or a combination
of these problems.
Papers, written assignments and exams that belong to
the D or F categories demonstrate inadequate command of the course material:
A D
paper, written assignment, or exam demonstrates serious deficiencies or clear
flaws in the students command of the course material or readings at hand.
And F
paper, written assignment, or exam demonstrates NO competence in the course or
reading materials. It indicates a students neglect or lack of effort in the
course.
I strongly
encourage you to come to my office hours (M 9:30-10:30am & T 3:30-5pm, or
by appointment) if you have questions or concerns either before an assignment is due, or concerning your performance in the
course. Graded assignments and exams will be returned in class. After two weeks
you can come by my office during office hours to pick up your assignments if
you have not picked them up in class. I do not e-mail grades during the
semester or at the end of the course. We address a great deal of material in
this course, and at times it will feel overwhelming. Please come and talk with
me if that is the case.
History 1010-100: Western Civilization to the 17th Century
Prof. Lester Fall 2010
Questions and Guidelines for the First Written
Assignment
Paper I: The Iliad and the World of the Ancient
Greeks:
Due: At the beginning of class, Monday September 20, 2010
Write a 5-page paper in response to one of the
questions below. Do a close reading of The
Iliad and craft a well thought-out and elegant essay. Your paper should
have a thesis that is clearly stated and should be grounded in the historical
context during which the epic poem was sung (ca. 1200-1000BC) and later written
down (ca. 750BC). Be sure to integrate quotations from the text to support your
argument and to end with a clear and insightful conclusion. You DO NOT need to
do any outside reading or research for this paper! I am looking for your own
personal reading and interpretation of this source, in your words.
1. Analyze how Achilles both
embodies and challenges the Greek ideal of arte
or excellence as a warrior hero. His status as a hero is built not only on his
skills, but also the development of his character throughout the epic poem. By
the end do you think Homer still intends him to be a hero?
2. Homer gives Greek and
Trojan women little to no role in warfare, but he depicts them as important in
determining the fate of cities, dynasties, and several heroes of the story.
Characterize the role and authority given to women in The Iliad. Be sure to consider the distinction between women who
are wives (queens and mothers) and women who are the prizes of men. You may
wish to focus on one particular woman.
3. The Iliad grapples with the tension between war and the chaos it
unleashes on the one hand, and civilization and ordered governance on the other.
Identify an emblematic scene or example of ordered civilization and discuss how
the Greeks understood this ideal.
Parenthetical citations will suffice for this
assignment, that is, simply give the book number, lines of the poem, and page
number of any quotations you use. For example: (Bk. 24, lns, 592--6, p. 605).
Any outside sources that you consult must be listed in a Works Cited page at
the end of the paper. For further details please speak with your TAs.