Results of the 1960 Election(1)

  Popular Votes Electoral Votes
First

Method

 
Kennedy 34,220,984 303
Nixon 34,108,157 219
Byrd 638,222 15(2)
Minor Parties 188,559 0
Total 69,155,922 537
Kennedy is a Plurality
more votes

winner; 112,827
than Nixon

 
Second

Method

 
Kennedy 34,049,976 303
Nixon 34,108,157 219
Byrd 491,527 15
Minor Parties 188,559 0
Total 68,838,219 537
Nixon is a Plurality
more votes

winner; 58,181
than Kennedy

 

First Method: involves counting the split Alabama elector slate for both Kennedy and unpledged electors as Kennedy votes; this was, in fact, what happened.
 

Second Method: involves dividing the vote for the Alabama Democratic elector slate proportionately according to its actual composition. A vote for JFK was his; not for JFK does not go to his vote total.

1. Lawrence D. Longley and Neal R. Pierce, (1996) "The Electoral College Primer" Yale University Press, New Haven, p. 49.

2. Byrd was accorded the votes of 14 unpledged electors from Alabama and Mississippi, plus one vote by a Republican elector from Oklahoma.