Competition Game Reviews
"His reviews are often better than the games they're about." -- Stephen Granade
One salient feature of the new wave in IF is the annual Interactive Fiction Competition, now in
its eighth year. Competition games are usually short works, which gives
authors the ability to stretch and experiment with the form. The
competition has seen an incredibly wide variety of works as a result.
One thing I did for nine years is try to provide
substantive feedback for competition authors in the form of reviews.
Below is a list of the games I've reviewed -- click on the game's title
to read the review. Note that although for voting purposes competition
games are rated on an integer scale of 1 to 10, I've taken the ratings
out to one decimal place for a little finer calibration.
I've linked
the game title in each review header to the appropriate directory at the
IF-Archive. If you're unfamiliar with IF file formats, you might take
a look at Stephen Griffiths' FAQ on the
subject. Also, if you're having trouble downloading these files with
a web browser, remember to right-click on the file name to
download it in binary format -- browsers don't typically recognize IF
file types.
Finally, just for fun I've compiled a couple of
plaintext listings of the competition games ordered according to the scores I gave
them. One listing separates the games by year, while the
other lumps them all together.
The only competition games missing from these listings should be:
- The 1995 competition games, about which I didn't write reviews.
- My own games Wearing the Claw, Earth And Sky, Another Earth, Another Sky, and Luminous Horizon, about which I can't be objective.
- The excellent games Mother Loose and All Roads, for which I was a beta-tester.
- The 1996 game Promoted!, which required the OS/2 operating system to run.
- The 2000 games Infil-Traitor and Happy Ever After, which had known bugs that required recompilation before the games were viable.
- The 2001 game Begegnung Am Fluss, which was in German.
- Games written by newsgroup trolls (defined by me as people who have made multiple, unprovoked, personal attacks on newsgroup regulars), which I don't have the ability or inclination to review fairly.
- Games from 2005 or later -- after my son was born I lost the time that used to go into these reviews.
IF Essays
This section is kind of a catch-all spot for things I've written about IF that are
neither games nor competition reviews.
Articles and Scribblings
In the spring of 1993, I was in the midst of a Master's Degree program in English
Literature at CU-Boulder, taking a
class in Literary Theory. At the same time, I had just rediscovered IF via the
Lost Treasures of Infocom packages. For my final project in that class, I wrote a
paper called Interactive Fiction and Reader-Response Criticism
. That paper was missing for quite some time, since it was written on a legacy
word processor and I had lost the file anyway. However, I found the hard copy in my
recent move and, eager to test out the OCR capabilities of my just-purchased scanner,
scanned it in, cleaned it up, and presented it here in text form. Naturally, it's not
the paper I would write today, having done much more thinking and acquired much more
knowledge about IF since the time I wrote it. However, it still might be interesting
to some people out there.
I also wrote an essay for the long-anticipated IF
Theory book called Landscape And Character In IF
I wrote an extensive review for the first book-length academic examination of
interactive fiction, Nick Montfort's excellent Twisty Little
Passages.
I wrote a few
IF Haikus that started a fun thread on the newsgroup.
Interviews
I've been interviewed a few times in various places:
- InsideADRIFT,
a fanzine for users of the ADRIFT IF development system.
- Terra D'IF
, an Italian IF zine.
- Duncan Stevens interviewed me in SPAG #31. It's rather odd to be
interviewed in one's own zine, but SPAG has a tradition of interviewing the top three
finishers in the IF comp, and I won that year. However, when I won the next time, SPAG
interviewed finishers 2-4.
Non-competition Game Reviews
I'm quite fond of Mark Musante's IF-Review,
which is currently the only site that pays for IF reviews. I've reviewed the following
games for Mark:
I wrote an advance review for The Act Of Misdirection, a
comp-sized game by Callico Harrison released in early 2004.
I've been asked to serve as a judge for a variety of mini-comps:
I've beta-tested some large games, and for a couple of them, I wrote the author a long
letter afterwards talking about my reactions. These letters were more or less informal
reviews, but I didn't release them as reviews at the time, since there's something less
than kosher about a betatester reviewing a game. Now, with the permission of the authors,
I'm reprinting those letters here. Please note that they can be rather spoilery.
I've also done some reviews of graphic adventure games, though I never manage to play them
until several years after they've been released, which is why I call them "Really Late
Reviews." They were originally hosted on Stephen Granade's site when it was a part of About.com.